The best yearbook companies for elementary schools
Most “best yearbook company” lists are written for high schools. This one compares seven yearbook companies, the publishers that print school yearbooks, for an elementary PTA volunteer with a few evenings a week. We make one of these products, so check the claims: we say where the other six are better.
Six things decide it: whether you must sign something, the minimum, the software volunteers must learn, whether each child gets anything of their own, who does the design, and how much margin the PTA keeps.
What you are committing to.
| Company | Contract or deposit | Minimum order | How you get a price | Fundraising margin |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Rethink Yearbooks | One-school-year agreement; no deposit, no multi-year term | None; prints only what is ordered | A clear starting price and a quote within one business day | School sets the family price; most add $2–5 a book |
| Jostens | Agreement with a rep; terms vary | Set inside your quote | Quoted by a rep | Set inside your quote |
| Lifetouch | Often written with a picture day agreement | Set inside your quote | Quoted by a rep | Set inside your quote |
| Treering | None | None; prints only what is ordered | Published online | School sets the family price |
| Shutterfly | None | None | Published online | Limited; consumer-style checkout |
| Herff Jones | Agreement with a rep; terms vary | Set inside your quote | Quoted by a rep | Set inside your quote |
| School Annual | Terms set in the online order | Set inside your order | Online sign-up, quoted specifics | Set inside your order |
Compiled from public vendor information, as of September 2026. Rep-sold vendors publish very little: ask for the minimum, term length and deposit in writing, and verify before you sign.
How the book actually gets made.
| Company | Design software | What each child gets | Who designs | Print + delivery |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Rethink Yearbooks | Canva; nothing proprietary to learn | In the shared pages; with personalization, myClass or myGrade pages built automatically from their own class and grade | Your team, or First Draft builds the first draft free and your team edits it in Canva | About 3 weeks; on time guaranteed when the book seals at least 3 weeks before you need it |
| Jostens | Proprietary (Yearbook Avenue) | One identical book | Your committee, with rep support and a large template library | Varies by plan and press date |
| Lifetouch | Proprietary online tool | One identical book; portraits flow in from picture day | Your committee, with rep support | Varies by plan and press date |
| Treering | Browser tool built for volunteers | Two custom pages a parent logs in and fills; extra pages cost more | Your committee | Varies; commonly a few weeks |
| Shutterfly | Consumer photo book editor | One identical book | Your committee, usually one or two people | Varies by product and shipping |
| Herff Jones | eDesign, paired with Canva | One identical book | Your staff, with the deepest adviser training in the category | Varies by plan and press date |
| School Annual | Vendor templates, ordered online | One identical book | Your committee | Varies by plan and press date |
How often a particular child appears in any book depends on how often they were photographed, at every vendor on this list. Software your volunteers have to learn.
What each company is genuinely good at.
Jostens
Real scale: decades of adviser resources, the widest range of covers and finishes, and a rep who will come to your school.
Best for: large schools, districts that require a national vendor
Herff Jones
The best yearbook education in the business: curriculum, workshops and training for a student staff.
Best for: schools teaching yearbook as journalism
Lifetouch
If Lifetouch shoots your picture day, the portrait handoff is seamless: no file to chase, one point of contact.
Best for: schools already under a picture day agreement
Treering
Published pricing, no minimum, and a browser tool a volunteer can learn in an afternoon. Prints only what families order, and plants a tree per book.
Best for: small schools that cannot risk unsold copies
Shutterfly
The lowest commitment on the list. Forty children in a preschool and no vendor relationship: a familiar consumer editor is right.
Best for: very small books
School Annual
Printing and templates through an online sign-up rather than a rep-led process.
Best for: schools that want Jostens without the meetings
Rethink Yearbooks, and where we do not fit
Built for a school from preschool to 8th grade where an unpaid coordinator wants a clear starting price and a fast quote, no deposit or multi-year term, Canva, and pages built automatically around each child’s class and grade for families who choose personalization.
The wrong answer if you run a high school journalism program that wants a professional design suite and adviser curriculum (Herff Jones or Jostens), or if your district mandates a national vendor.
Best for: preschool to 8th grade schools run by volunteers
Five questions, in this order.
- How many books will you actually sell? Under a hundred, minimums decide this. Over two hundred, margin starts to matter.
- Who does the design work, by name? If the answer is “me, somehow,” weight this above everything else.
- Are you tied to picture day? Bundled agreements quietly stop you shopping. Find out whether yours can be separated.
- What does the PTA need the book to raise? Work out the per-book margin, then see which vendors let you set the family price.
- When is your last day of school? Count back the printing time, then proofing. That is your real deadline. The coordinator’s guide →
Download the vendor comparison worksheet (PDF) Word version
Planning a yearbook? Get a quote and a sample.
Once you have a shortlist: how to make an elementary school yearbook and what it costs.
Head-to-head detail.
One vendor at a time, including where they beat us. Balfour and Picaboo are compared only here:
- Rethink vs. Jostens →
- Rethink vs. Lifetouch →
- Rethink vs. Treering →
- Rethink vs. Balfour →
- Rethink vs. Picaboo →
- Rethink vs. Walsworth →
- Rethink vs. Memory Book Company →
- Signs it is time to switch, and how →
Also: elementary yearbooks at Rethink, what First Draft is and is not, our pricing.
Choosing a yearbook company, answered.
Which yearbook company is best for an elementary school?
It depends on what is scarce. If time, pick a vendor that designs your first draft and gives a clear starting price and a fast quote. If money, pick one with no minimum. If you have a picture day agreement, the vendor that shoots your portraits is often the least work. Rethink is built for the first case: schools from preschool to 8th grade run by a volunteer.
Do yearbook companies require a contract or a deposit?
Some do. Rep-sold vendors such as Jostens, Herff Jones and Lifetouch generally work from a signed agreement, sometimes bundled with picture day. Online vendors such as Treering, Shutterfly and Rethink do not use binding multi-year contracts or deposits. Read your current agreement before you assume you are locked in.
What is the minimum order for a school yearbook?
It varies. Treering, Shutterfly and Rethink have no minimum and print only what is ordered. Rep-quoted vendors set the minimum inside your quote, so ask for it in writing.
Can we switch yearbook companies mid-year?
Usually yes, if you are not inside a signed term. There is no design file to migrate: you start again from the photos you have collected. Check your agreement, then confirm the new vendor can deliver before your last day of school.
See what your school’s
book would cost.
A per-book quote and a sample with one child’s real class and grade pages — no deposit, no multi-year term, free first draft.